By Megan Riedlinger
6:45pm PDT, Aug 23, 2021
Whether or not it is your responsible pleasure or your open obsession, there isn’t any denying the leisure worth that the “The Bachelor” franchises convey to our tv units on Monday nights. And although it does not have the very best monitor file for resulting in lasting love, the aftermath of the insane breakups present mounds of gossip fodder we all the time lap up. In honor of the return of “Bachelor in Paradise” — season 7 debuted in August 2021 — Wonderwall.com is rounding up the messiest Bachelor Nation breakups, beginning with this drama… Amanda Stanton first joined the “The Bachelor” world throughout Ben Higgins’ season, making it to the ultimate 4. Although her first “Bachelor” breakup was comparatively drama-free, her subsequent would not be. She later met “The Bachelorette” alum Josh Murray on “Bachelor in Paradise” in 2016, and their relationship culminated in an on-screen proposal that September. After the present aired, Josh moved from Georgia to stay with Amanda and her two daughters in Southern California and issues gave the impression to be going properly… till December. A heated battle led to a break up; Amanda claimed that Josh refused to confess it was over after she broke up with him, even going as far as to share Instagram posts pretending they have been nonetheless a pair after the actual fact. Although they have been on-again, off-again in early 2017, issues have been positively over by March. From there, issues simply bought extra sophisticated: The cops bought concerned over a shared automotive and Josh launched an announcement to E! Information at one level threatening to take authorized motion in opposition to Amanda. Yikes. Sadly, that is not Amanda’s solely messy breakup with a member of Bachelor Nation…
Maintain studying to take a stroll down reminiscence lane and relive extra of essentially the most dramatic breakups within the franchise’s historical past…
RELATED: All the leading ladies of “The Bachelorette”: Where are they now?
Amanda Stanton and Robby Hayes hit it off after assembly on “Bachelor in Paradise” in 2017, with Robby sweetly preventing to win Amanda’s coronary heart on the seashores of Mexico. Sadly, as quickly as they bought again to the true world, issues have been very, very totally different. The 2 not solely break up however made their breakup public by airing their soiled laundry on Twitter. Robby shared a prolonged put up with a brutal sign-off: “Historical past is repeatedly exhibiting that some folks thrive off of utilizing the media and their ‘military’ to govern viewers to position one-sided blame, continually play the ‘sufferer’ and use their buddies to attempt to assassinate one’s character. Your story-line is getting OLD; sooner or later it is simply on YOU to cease residing a double-life, and at this level, everybody sees by way of it. God bless.” Amanda did not hold quiet after studying his assault: She retaliated by sharing a photograph of Robby making out with one other girl. The fallout from their uncivilized break up continued on lengthy after the breakup too, like when Amanda alluded to an ex who requested she proceed to pay for his Disneyland annual cross. Although she did not identify names, Robby fired again — and within the course of outed himself because the thriller ex whereas claiming her tweet wasn’t completely correct. The ethical of the story right here? Maintain your relationship drama off Twitter!
RELATED: Biggest scandals in “The Bachelor” and “The Bachelorette” history
Jake Pavelka and Vienna Girardi’s nightmarish finish created a completely new episode of tv for ABC. All through season 14 of “The Bachelor,” Vienna was portrayed because the villain as she butted heads with the opposite ladies on her strategy to the highest. And although Jake did not thoughts warnings from the opposite women — he solely noticed the nice in Vienna throughout — their relationship imploded shortly after the finale episode. Their vicious phrases in opposition to one another precipitated ABC to offer them much more tv in 2010 — a sit-down mediated by then-host Chris Harrison during which each got the chance to air their facet of the story. Spoiler alert: It did not finish properly. Vienna accused Jake of being a “fame w****” and he accused her of undermining him, ultimately infamously erupting throughout their spat, “Please cease interrupting me!” Sadly (or thankfully?) for “The Bachelor” followers, they shared display time as soon as extra after they each appeared on the second season of the now-defunct “Bachelor Pad,” although at that time Vienna had already moved on to “The Bachelorette” contestant Kasey Kahl (sure, the man who bought a six-inch tattoo for Ali Fedotowsky throughout her season).
RELATED: Final couples of “The Bachelor” and “The Bachelorette”: Where are they now?
After Peter Weber proposed to contestant Hannah Ann Sluss in Australia on the finish of season 24, producers and a digital camera crew tagged alongside just a few weeks later as he later modified his thoughts and dumped her — basically explaining he nonetheless had emotions for the runner-up, Madison Prewett, who had opted to ship herself dwelling previous to his proposal. A messy reunion ensued stay after the finale aired, with Hannah Ann confronting him and uttering the beautiful scathing line that can go down in Bachelor Nation historical past: “If you wish to be with a girl, you want to turn out to be an actual man.” Ouch!
One other villain who ended up snagging the ultimate rose? Courtney Robertson, who was Ben Flajnik’s polarizing remaining choose throughout season 16 of “The Bachelor” despite the fact that a lot of her fellow contestants brazenly despised her. Like Jake Pavelka earlier than him, Ben stayed true to his coronary heart and valiantly picked the mannequin in the long run (for her character, clearly). They broke up shortly after taping the finale and getting engaged in November 2011 — all due to a dishonest scandal involving Ben and three ladies over the course of a weekend in San Francisco (and photographic proof through Us Weekly). It made for an ungainly “After the Ultimate Rose” particular taping in March 2012, the place Ben claimed that seeing Courtney’s habits on the present because it aired made him doubt his selection. However the two finally determined to get again collectively although — no shocker right here — it did not final. They’d break up by that October.
Bachelor followers knew Evan Bass from JoJo Fletcher’s “The Bachelorette” season 13, and Carly Waddell was identified for competing for Chris Soules’ love on season 19 of “The Bachelor” earlier than they united on season 3 of “Bachelor in Paradise” in 2016. Evan had a crush on Carly, who did not fairly reciprocate at first, however ultimately got here round. They wed in 2017 and had two children collectively earlier than calling it quits in 2020. Carly defined issues to her followers on YouTube in January 2021, sharing, “We separated the day after Thanksgiving. We have been going to remedy for years… We tried. We tried, y’all, for a extremely very long time to make it work.”
Matt James picked Rachael Kirkconnell on the finish of season 25, however he did not suggest. Nonetheless, Matt stated he was dedicated to Rachael and envisioned her as his spouse. Nonetheless, not lengthy after the finale was filmed (however earlier than it aired), three-year-old social media posts surfaced exhibiting Rachael at an Antebellum-themed social gathering. On the “After the Ultimate Rose” particular, Matt stated he and Rachael have been now not collectively and acknowledged that her previous racist acts have been the rationale why. This is what occurred when he discovered the Web rumors about Rachael’s previous have been true: “It was in that second and the dialog that I had [with her] that [I realized] Rachael won’t perceive what it means to be Black in America,” he stated. “It is heartbreaking. In case you do not perceive that one thing like that’s problematic in 2018, there’s a variety of me that you simply will not perceive. It is so simple as that.” Rachael, in the meantime, stated she was nonetheless in love with Matt, however he basically squashed any hopes for a reconciliation, saying that she must confront her racist actions and work on herself. “After I questioned our relationship, it was within the context of you not totally understanding my Blackness and what it means to be a Black man in America,” he informed her. “It broke my coronary heart as a result of that is the final dialog I assumed we might be having. I did not signal as much as have this dialog.” The pair, nonetheless, reconciled within the months that adopted and began relationship once more.
Arie Luyendyk Jr., season 22’s star in 2018, deserves a spot within the Bachelor Nation corridor of fame for what was hands-down the messiest (and most controversial!) breakup within the franchise’s historical past. Not solely did he renege on his remaining choose — dumping Becca Kufrin weeks after proposing — however he allowed “The Bachelor” cameras to roll whereas he broke up along with her. Their awkward encounter aired on nationwide tv earlier than cameras adopted him as he pleaded with runner-up Lauren Burnham to take him again. However all’s properly that ends properly: In 2019, Arie married second choose Lauren; they’ve since welcomed three children. As for Becca? She grew to become the star of “The Bachelorette” and went on to stay along with her No. 1 (and solely!) choose, Garrett Yrigoyen, earlier than ending issues in 2020.
Jason Mesnick is the OG messy “The Bachelor” breakup king: He gave viewers the alternative of a fairy-tale ending tied up with a bow throughout season 13. Jason initially picked Melissa Rycroft (second from left), solely to comprehend that he appreciated his runner-up, Molly Malaney (proper), extra. He broke up with Melissa on stay tv throughout the “After the Ultimate Rose” particular, main Melissa to name him names. He then requested Molly out proper after. But it surely did not all finish terribly — Jason and Molly are one of many solely profitable {couples} in “The Bachelor” historical past, as they’re nonetheless married and are elevating two children collectively.
Byron Velvick and Mary Delgado had a reasonably long term, however finally could not make it work. They met throughout season 6 of “The Bachelor” in 2004 and Byron requested Mary to be his spouse with an adorably memorable proposal on the finale: He spoke in Spanish so her mother and father may perceive after they watched. Sadly, their courtship wasn’t as candy. In 2007, Mary was arrested for assaulting Byron, and although they labored by way of it, finally, their bond wasn’t sturdy sufficient to outlive. They by no means made it to the altar and ended issues in 2009 after 5 years collectively.
Brad Womack’s first enterprise on “The Bachelor” noticed him dump not one however two of his remaining women directly throughout season 11. He broke it off with each DeAnna Pappas and Jenni Croft on the final episode, surprising viewers as he determined he would not give a “false promise,” claiming he cared concerning the ladies however thought it was higher to allow them to each stroll. Surprisingly, “The Bachelor” producers let him return for season 15… which leads us to our subsequent messy breakup…
Throughout Brad Womack’s second attempt at love when he appeared on “The Bachelor” season 15, it felt like he and Emily Maynard have been meant to be. Sadly, issues weren’t as hunky-dory as producers made them appear. Brad ended up breaking apart with Emily through an e-mail to the present’s producers after the season ended! Yep, rumor has it that Emily, who went on to star on “The Bachelorette,” discovered that her relationship was over when she was cc’d on the e-mail.
Andi Dorfman joined Bachelor Nation when she signed on to compete for the love of probably the most hated “The Bachelor” leads of all time — Juan Pablo Galavis. Although she did not make it to the very finish, her breakup on his season was cringe-worthy sufficient to make this record. After their fantasy suite date, Andi opened up about her emotions and confessed that she wasn’t in love with Juan Pablo — solely to listen to “It is OK” repeated again and again. Contemplating it had turn out to be considered one of Juan Pablo’s signature traces, it precipitated Andi to vent, “I need to die if I’ve to listen to ‘it is OK’ once more.” However do not cry for Andi, as a result of this memorable second helped her acquire a spot as the subsequent “The Bachelorette” star in 2014. Sadly, her breakup with the winner of that season is on deck…
These two are each repeat offenders relating to horrible Bachelor Nation breakups! Andi Dorfman picked Josh Murray on the finish of her stint on season 10 of “The Bachelorette,” selecting him over Nick Viall (who we’ll get to quickly!), however the two did not go the space and had a less-than-amicable finish to their engagement. Although followers weren’t aware of the small print on the time, Andi later wrote a guide, “It is Not OK: Turning Heartbreak Into Fortunately Ever After,” during which she chronicled their very messy breakup and accused Josh of being emotionally and verbally abusive throughout their time collectively. As for Josh, he shared an Instagram put up forward of Colton Underwood’s season of “The Bachelor” in 2019 with a satan emoji protecting Andi’s face of their proposal image — proving that years later, there was nonetheless dangerous blood between these two.
Andi Dorfman bought caught in Nick Viall’s internet when he competed for her coronary heart on “The Bachelorette” in 2014. Although he made it to the ultimate two, finally Andi did not choose him on the finish. So what did Nick do? In case you thought he headed off into the sundown together with his head held excessive, you would be mistaken. Nope, as a substitute, he waited till the “After the Ultimate Rose” particular to awkwardly put Andi on blast, sharing that the 2 have been intimate throughout filming and painfully asking, “Why did you make like to me if you happen to weren’t in love with me?” throughout the particular… the place her fiancé, Josh Murray, was inside earshot.
When it was Desiree Hartsock’s flip to search for love on season 9 of “The Bachelorette,” there was one clear frontrunner — Brooks Forester. Brooks was so clearly the person Desiree needed that when he informed her he needed to go away throughout their fantasy suite date, Desiree almost give up the present completely. Happily for followers — and Desiree herself — she soldiered on and ended up accepting a proposal from Chris Siegfried. They’re now married with two children!
It was the messiest breakup that… wasn’t? Colton Underwood clearly solely had eyes for Cassie Randolph throughout his time because the lead on “The Bachelor” season 23, so when she tried to go dwelling after telling him she wasn’t able to get engaged, he did not take the information flippantly. As an alternative, Colton begged and pleaded for Cassie to remain and when she left, he jumped a fence and ran away from manufacturing as cameramen and producers desperately chased after him. As soon as he collected himself (after producers tracked him down!), Colton despatched the remainder of the remaining ladies dwelling and made one remaining try to sway Cassie. This time it labored, and the 2 determined to proceed relationship with no ring or any future plans. They break up for good in 2020 and in 2021, Colton publicly revealed he’s gay.
One on-screen “The Bachelorette” break up that hit followers arduous? The breakup between Rachel Lindsay, season 13’s “The Bachelorette” lead, and Peter Kraus, which was probably the most real, uncooked, emotional moments the truth present has produced. When Rachel’s high choose determined he wasn’t prepared to vow Rachel an engagement ring, he let her know. Rachel defined that she needed to go away the present with a fiancé, not only a boyfriend, and the 2 realized they have been at an deadlock. Many tears adopted, and Rachel’s faux eyelashes famously got here off within the course of as she stated her remaining goodbye.
Season 11 of “The Bachelorette” featured fan favourite Kaitlyn Bristowe falling in love with Shawn Sales space. She accepted his proposal in 2015 and the 2 gave the impression to be going sturdy… till November 2018 after they introduced their breakup after greater than three years collectively. Kaitlyn quickly opened up concerning the break up on her podcast, noting that they disagreed on “vital basic values.” Later, Shawn revealed on Ben Higgins and Ashley Iaconetti’s “Nearly Well-known: In Depth” podcast that they’d truly damaged up two months previous to their announcement. He additionally famous how troublesome it was to see her already in a severe relationship with one more Bachelor Nation castoff, Jason Tartick, with whom Kaitlyn went public in January 2019 (they bought engaged in 2021). “I believe simply along with her transferring on so fast, I simply have a tricky time understanding why she could be placing this out all over the place or blasting it everywhere realizing that it may harm,” Shawn defined. However in Might 2019 throughout an look on E!’s “Ladygang,” Kaitlyn revealed who broke up with whom: “He left me,” she stated. “He did not know why he could not love me.”
It appeared like the primary season of “Bachelor in Paradise” in 2014 may need sparked an actual romance between Marcus Grodd and Lacy Faddoul. Marcus, who’d appeared on season 10 of “The Bachelorette,” proposed to Lacy, who followers knew from season 18 of “The Bachelor,” and the 2 had a marriage in Mexico on the season 2 premiere of “BiP” in 2015. However all was not because it appeared: Lacy refused to make their union authorized as soon as they bought again to the US. By March 2016, they have been accomplished. Marcus later informed Us Weekly about their unusual faux marriage, sharing that they solely had minimal contact after their Mexico marriage ceremony and that he felt “performed” by the wonder.
